Best Mattresses in NYC

Contents

Best Mattresses of 2025: Our Testing Expert Results.
Choosing the right mattress is key to a good night’s sleep and well-being. “Mattresses NYC” is your independent guide to the best mattresses and sleep products from the best brands in New York City. Below, you’ll find our top-ranked mattresses, tailored to various needs and preferences. We’ve done the research, providing reviews, ratings, and comparisons to help you make an informed decision. Let us guide you to a better sleep experience.

Our Rankings and Ratings

Top 20 Mattresses of 2025

Top 20 Mattresses of 2025

Brand Size
Brand / Model
Comfort
Height
Type
Rating
Ships from
3 days
Twin - $185.50
Twin XL - $185.50
Full - $232.40
BB Kids Mattress Firm 6 Memory Foam 10/10 3 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $1153.60
Twin XL - $1223.60
Full - $1433.60
Queen - $1678.60
Short Queen - $1678.60
King - $1853.60
California King - $1853.60
RV King - $1853.60
Titan Plus Elite Mattress Medium 14.5 Hybrid 10/10 3 days View Details
7 days
Twin XL - $2249
Full - $2359
Queen - $2389
King - $2999
California King - $2999
Estate Lifetime 8 Mattress Firm 14 Hybrid 10/10 7 days View Details
5 days
Twin - $4199
Twin XL - $4499
Full - $6199
Queen - $6499
King - $7999
California King - $7999
Halcyon Azure Mattress Medium 11 Hybrid 10/10 5 days View Details
5 days
Twin - $6199
Twin XL - $6499
Full - $9599
Queen - $9999
King - $11999
California King - $11999
Halcyon Elysium Mattress Medium 15 Hybrid 10/10 5 days View Details
1 days
Twin XL - $1999
Queen - $3299
King - $3799
California King - $3799
Split King - $3998
Puffy Monarch Mattress Soft 16 Hybrid 10/10 1 days View Details
1 days
Twin - $1249
Twin XL - $1449
Full - $2149
Queen - $2399
King - $2699
California King - $2699
Split King - $2898
Puffy Royal Hybrid Mattress Soft 14 Hybrid 10/10 1 days View Details
1 days
Twin - $899
Twin XL - $1049
Full - $1299
Queen - $1499
King - $1699
California King - $1699
Split King - $2098
Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress Medium 12 Hybrid 10/10 1 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $839.30
Twin XL - $1025.50
Full - $1305.50
Queen - $1585.50
King - $1865.50
California King - $1865.50
Split California King - $1025.50
Short Queen - $1585.50
RV King - $1865.50
RV Bunk - $1585.50
Aurora Luxe Mattress Firm, Medium, Soft 13.25 Hybrid 9/10 3 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $372.40
Twin XL - $512.40
Full - $559.30
Queen - $652.40
King - $792.40
California King - $792.40
Brooklyn Essential Mattress Medium 10 Hybrid 9/10 3 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $874.30
Twin XL - $1084.30
Full - $1399.30
Queen - $1679.30
King - $2029.30
California King - $2029.30
Split California King - $1084.30
Short Queen - $1679.30
Sedona Elite Mattress Medium 10.75 Innerspring 9/10 3 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $769.30
Twin XL - $944.30
Full - $1206.80
Queen - $1399.30
King - $1679.30
California King - $1679.30
Split California King - $944.30
Spartan Mattress Medium 13 Hybrid 9/10 3 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $646.80
Twin XL - $716.80
RV Queen - $1212.40
Full - $821.80
Queen - $1072.40
King - $1212.40
California King - $1212.40
Split California King - $716.80
Short Queen - $1072.40
Olympic Queen - $1212.40
RV King - $1212.40
Plank Firm Luxe Mattress Extra Firm, Firm 11.25 Hybrid 9/10 3 days View Details
3 days
Twin - $928.90
Twin XL - $1022
Full - $1115.10
Queen - $1208.90
King - $1395.10
California King - $1395.10
EcoSleep Luxe Mattress Medium 11 Hybrid 9/10 3 days View Details
7 days
Twin - $879.00
Twin XL - $939.00
Full - $1049.00
Queen - $1348.00
King - $1699.00
California King - $1699.00
St. Regis Mattresses Firm 11.5 Hybrid 9/10 7 days View Details
7 days
Twin - $1109
Twin XL - $1169
Full - $1439
Queen - $1499
King - $1989
California King - $1989
Estate 5000 Mattress Firm 12.5 Hybrid 9/10 7 days View Details
7 days
Twin XL - $2469
Full - $2699
Queen - $2769
King - $3499
California King - $3499
Estate Lifetime 9 Mattress Medium 15 Hybrid 9/10 7 days View Details
7 days
Twin XL - $2619
Full - $2839
Queen - $2949
King - $3699
California King - $2699
Estate Lifetime 10 Mattress Soft 15 Hybrid 9/10 7 days View Details
7 days
Twin - $2609
Twin XL - $1789
Full - $1939
Queen - $1989
King - $2589
California King - $2589
Estate SE-GL Mattress Soft 14 Hybrid 9/10 7 days View Details
7 days
Twin - $899
Twin XL - $959
Full - $1119
Queen - $1189
King - $1389
California King - $1389
Real Bed Mattress Firm 11 Hybrid 9/10 7 days View Details
Show More

Doctor's Recommendations

Dr. Liebenson Review
Dr. Liebenson
Director of L.A. Sports & Spine

How to Choose a Mattress? It is one of the most critical research areas for general health, athletic performance, and pain management, but most importantly, your overall well-being. Lack of appropriate sleep occurs for several reasons. Back pain is a leading factor in sub-optimal sleep. A key question is, what can you do to improve your sleep? Your mattress plays a significant role in sleep hygiene. It’s not the only aspect either since room temperature, timing of caffeine intake and meals, electronics exposure, and so much more also affect how restful your sleep is. Picking a mattress should be based on whether it fits you and if it is comfortable rather than if it has certain gimmicks or space-age tech. Now that you know the parts that affect your comfort from a mattress, by reading this article, you now have the tools to choose a mattress not because it is expensive but because it brings you comfort. Everyone deserves a good sleep; you must know how to find it.

quote quote

Expert Opinions

Expert
Dr. Ronald Primas
MD, FACP, FACPM, DABIHM

Internal Medicine & Integrative Health Specialist.
“I am just writing to let you know how pleased I am with purchasing our king-sized Naturepedic mattress. As an internal medicine and integrative medicine physician, I understand the power of sleep for my patients, my family, and myself. Not only is a good night’s sleep important, the vehicle of sleep is just as important. I appreciate that Naturepedic uses quality, natural, organic materials in all its products. The detriment of having petroleum and volatile organic compounds in other high-end mattresses has only recently been addressed, with the off-gassing of volatile organics causing significant morbidities like headaches and sinus congestion. I invested much time investigating my mattress purchase and decided to purchase a Naturepedic mattress. My bed is now truly my “safe space” 🙂 I highly recommend your product to my family, friends, and patients. Thank you.” travelmd.com

quote quote